Euro 2008: Let’s help Scolari!

Choose Portugal’s attack for Austria & Switzerland

To open our new Fanszone section we will be focussing on the national team in the build-up to the Euro 2008 tournament in June this year.

Luiz Felipe Scolari has been busy rebuilding the side since World Cup 2006. Over the coming weeks, PortuGOAL will give fans the chance to examine the Brazilian’s options and (attempt to) arrive at conclusions to guarantee a Portugal team ready to take on allcomers in Switzerland and Austria.

To start with we’ll be concentrating on the forward line. Below Orlando Mac and Alberto Mourinho give their views on which players to pick. Do you agree? Join the debate by using the form at the bottom of the page.


by Orlando Mac
Freaking fantastic forwards:
Unleash a four-pronged attack

I descended from two men that in ancient times defended Portuguese honour by chopping down the door of a Castelo, which the Moors had seized, to help free our people. They were nicknamed the Machado Brothers so bear with me as I might have to chop down a few doors for your entertainment.

I being one of Scolari’s harshest critics actually feel that he is headed into his strongest area. He is a tournament boss and one of the most important ones lies ahead, not since Eusebio or the Golden Generation who stalked their prey has there been such a talented set of forwards. I believe this crop is by far the most talented group ever assembled by the “Selecção das Quinas.”

Spoilt for choice we can pick from a group of forwards that could start for almost any squad on the planet.

So to help Scolari (before he starts throwing punches), the kind folks at PortuGoal thought we could help him build a winning squad.

Almeida up to the task

First the striker and with a 33% strike rate for Portugal we lumber that task on Almeida (8 gls Werder Bremen). Let’s just hope he gets some service, our front men have been known to go hungry often.

As for the next line of attack Portugal is blessed (with a creative bunch that roves) from side to side, so why not ratchet up the confusion with 3 floating forwards in a 3-1 formation.

Up the middle I feel Ronaldo (30 gls ManU) could create havoc either supporting the striker or moving up to strike alongside Almeida or exchanging with the wing to stretch the defence with a tantalizing run. He would be our maestro.

On his left I would put Nani (3 gls ManU, he crosses the best of the three) to help feed Cristiano and Almeida down the middle.

On the right contrary to what most might think I would play Quaresma (5 gls Porto), his play of late has been better than his usual performances for “as Quinas.” Now if he could get one cross to its actual destination or hit the target with more than just 1 out of 30, I would be impressed.

This formation I believe is the most formidable and with strong leadership they will light up the tournament and strike the fear of our forefathers into the hearts of every defender in their wake.


by Alberto Mourinho
Ronaldo-Quaresma-Almeida:
The dream ticket

People talk about it being difficult for Scolari to choose out of Ronaldo, Quaresma, Nani and Simao for Portugal and who should be the main striker. Some say the Brazilian has a hard job. I disagree.

Football is a simple game and the answer is simple. Cristiano Ronaldo is the best player in the world and one that every other country would like to have, period. His best position is as a winger. So let’s forget these ludicrous ideas of playing the best winger in the world out of position as a striker. No. Ronaldo is a winger and must be left there to terrorise defences.

The second winger has to be Quaresma. In terms of pure skill, the Porto winger is a match for Ronaldo, maybe having even more tricks. Having less of an explosion and less speed he relies more on his amazing skills. So having the two wingers with different styles will cause different problems for the opposition defenders. They can also both switch wings easily during a game, which will also help to confuse defenders.

Nani is very similar to Ronaldo, while Simao has never played great for the national team.

Striker a must

As for the striker debate, we all know that Portugal has struggled to produce good strikers over the years. But with the ammunition supplied from Ronaldo and Quaresma it would be a crime not to include an out-and-out striker. I still believe Almeida can be the long-term solution for Portugal. He needs to be given a run in the team to learn when to make his runs and get full benefit from the service of the wingers.

Simao and Nani are great options to bring on as substitutes for Ronaldo & Quaresma if the match is already won or if they start to get tired or get injured. In an emergency, Ronaldo can be moved into the middle to back up Almeida and Simao or Nani should be brought on the field and take off a defender or defensive midfielder.

This I truly believe will bring success to the national team. And I am not blinded by my club loyalty to Benfica. I shall always support Simao and Gomes who did great things for my club in the past. But I recognise they cannot be in the national team right now. I’m a Portugal fan first, a Benfiquista second. Please give feedback!


Would you like to contribute with an opinion article? If so please send it (400 words max) to fanszone@portugoal.net.
Next topic: Portugal midfield



Your comments
  • Antonio F. Moreira, Malta (Portugal)
    10/05/2008 16:15
    Starting:

    GK Ricardo
    LB Caneira
    CB Fernando Meira
    CB Pepe
    RB Bosingwa
    DM Miguel Veloso
    LW Quaresma
    RW Ronaldo
    AM Deco
    CF Maniche
    ST Almeida


    Bench Choice:

    GK Quim
    GK (Rui Patricio)
    CB Ricardo Carvalho
    CB Bruno Alves
    CD (Pedro Emmanuel)
    DR Miguel
    DR (P.Ferreira)
    RW Simao
    MC Raul Meireles
    ST Nuno Gomes or ST Helder Postiga (On Bench)
    MC (Petit)
    MC (Moutinho)

    For me the most important thing is that Quaresma will be included in the line-up especially in the first eleven...ok im a supporter of FC Porto but still with Quaresma and C.Ronaldo on the Wings we will have a STRONG Wings and with Bosingwa Comes Up it will be great!! Deco and Maniche will be the Rocket Lauchers for me and Veloso is a Gladiator to defend and Defence ?? Caneira was good in the recent games but still we need another Left Defender adn in the middle ? Bruno Alves can be exchanged with Pepe but Meira is great!! and finally Right Defence?? Bosignwa is Amazing but Miguel is gr8 too i didnt chose Miguel because of the lack of matched he had recently. Captian? I'm still not sure who will be good to be a Captain maybe Deco? i don't really know whos best.

    But finally!! all I care is that we WIN!! lol even if we play with street guys!! the most important is the Portugese Flag!!
  • Chris, Ft. Myers, FL
    09/05/2008 13:39
    GK. Ricardo
    RB Paulo Ferreira
    CB Ricardo Carvalho (captain)
    CB Bruno Alves
    LB Jorge Ribeiro
    MF Maniche
    MF Moutinho
    LW Simao
    RW Ronaldo
    ST Nuno Gomes
    ST Hugo Almeida

    Subs: Quim
    Pepe
    Deco
    Petit
    Quaresma
    Meira
    Nani
    Pele
    Miguel Veloso
  • Daniel Wood-Costa, Ashford England
    09/05/2008 08:56
  • Yan Su, Qinhuangdao,PR China
    06/05/2008 07:07
    FC:Hugo Almeida
    AMC:joao MOutinho
    AML:Ricardo Quaresma
    AMR:Cristiano Ronaldo
    MC:M.Fernandes
    DM:Miguel Vesolo
    DR:Bosingwa
    DC:Pepe
    DC:Ricardo Cavalho
    DL:Jorge Ribeiro
  • Tony Lima, Marysville, CA USA
    26/04/2008 05:10
    Orlandomac, it is always a pleasure to read your insights and analysis. This forum is an excellent e-community for us Portuguese who have come to lands far from our fathers. I live in a community where there are few Portuguese so it is a pleasure to be able to identify and bond with fellow bethren in the Portuguese soccer cause.

    I would agree that our selection must favor a younger team that can play together for 10 years. I recall the emergence of Portugal at Euro 96 and it was a pretty young team mixed in with experienced players.
    Euro 2008 offers an opportunity to dawn a new era. A few people have astutely mentioned that Yannik is starting to emerge. He was injured earlier in the year and his recent good form may not be enough to earn a call up but he brings speed up front. He maybe not be a back to the goal striker but he is promising and offers at this point our best hope for the future. I don't think he will get a call up but I would like to see Scolari take a chance. It can't hurt. I hope he is the long term solution but we need to see if he can maintain his development.
    At this point I'm done lamenting about our lack of a true quality striker and look forward to going with what we got and hope they can put 5-6 good games together.
  • ,
    23/04/2008 17:07
    Portugal's squad should be:

    Starting 11

    GK Quim
    LB Bosingwa
    CB Fernando Meira
    CB Ricardo Carvalho
    RB Miguel
    CM Tiago
    LW Simao
    RW Ronaldo
    AM Deco
    CF Maniche
    ST Almeida

    BENCH:

    GK Ricardo
    GK Santos
    CB Andrade
    CB Bruno Alves
    CM Petit
    RW Quaresma
    LW Nani
    ST Nuno Gomes
    ST Helder Postiga
    CM Veloso
    CM Moutinho

  • Miguel Dias, Brampton Ontario Canada
    23/04/2008 02:03
    You guys have all lost your minds. Joao Moutinho does not fit any where the field for a 4-2-3-1 formation, he is a terrible defensive mid, and cant compare to Deco in the Offensive mid area. Starting line goes

    ST: Nuno Gomes (I hate to say it. but we have no one else)
    AM: C. Rondaldo
    AM: Deco
    AM: Simao (experience and speed Quaresma is to inconsistant)
    DM: Maniche
    DM: F Meira (Yes he can play Defensive Mid and has) OR Miguel Veloso
    LB: P. Ferreira (Caneira is absolutely TERRIBLE)
    CB: Ricardo Carvalho (Captain)
    CB: Pepe
    RB Bosingwa

    Subs
    Miguel
    Bruno Alves
    J. Ribeiro
    Petit
    Ricardo
    Postiga
    Nani
    Quaresma
  • Vdhazer, Aizawl, India
    22/04/2008 14:32
    Thank you very much Mr. Alec, Amsterdam for reading through all the articles posted and saying to us hello or whatever. Ok, I will ask you one-thing, by what means do you used the word “expertise (power).” I really don’t know what is it, even Orlando Mac or Ramos from Toronto will no understand I presume. But I really love your article replying us. I don't thing anyone wants to know about Amsterdam or about your expertise (power). See, we have a lot of experience in this field. But, generally, your so kind. I hope I will see many more articles from you with regard to your (power).
    Okay, all the way from India, Thanks....
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    18/04/2008 01:19
    Tony excellent analysis and you are so very correct in your assertion that we are all passionate about the national team, and this is great friendly banter.
    You stated your ideas eloquently.
    I ranked your squad highly when selecting mine, much for the same reasons.. but then chose to go with Portugal's strength and introduce a young team that would play with each other for possibly another 10 yrs. I figured in the end they would learn to share the ball and we would prosper with silverware for it. So with the emphasis on youth and talent I drew up my squad and formation.

    It is a pleasure to read such insight from others.. that goes for many of the other posters on here.

    Cheers Gentlemen
  • Matthew, Canada
    17/04/2008 23:14
    I dont think Scolari knows what he is doing as coach right now.
    First hes picking the wrong players to start,Caneira,Maniche,Martins.
    These players do not deserve to be starters.Another problem Scolari has is picking the right SUBS J.Ribeiro,Raul,Petit,Makukula etc These players are horrible and are useless. He also leaves the wrong players out of the squad J.Moutinho,Miguel,Veloso,
    M.Fernandes and Tiago these are good players and can lead the team to good victories and make chances. Players that should be starting are the ones who start for there Club like R.Carvalho,C.Ronaldo,R.Quaresma,
    B.Alves,Bosingwa etc.
    Scolari also has players like Nani,Deco,Pepe,Almeida,Meira who are willing to play at any moment and can contribute to the team we have seen it.There are players like Y.Djalo,Abel,Rui Patricio
    Eduardo,Quim,Postiga,Nelson who are yet to make a app and can still play well.Now the fact that he wants Nani,Ronaldo,Quaresma together, thats a good move all 3 are young and very talented,they can lead teams to victories,Another Pair i would love to see is Veloso,Deco and Moutinho with Almeida as the Striker.Now that is beautiful.

    ST:Hugo Almeida
    CAM:Deco
    LWM:Nani
    RWM:C.Ronaldo(C)
    LCM:Veloso
    RCM:Joao Moutinho
    LB:P.Ferreira
    LCB:R.Carvalho
    RCB:B.Alves
    RB:Bosingwa
    GK:Quim

    SUBS:

    ST:Postiga
    ST:Y.Djalo
    ST:N.Gomes
    M:Maniche
    M:Simao
    M:M.Fernandes
    M:R.Quaresma
    M:Tiago
    D/M:Meira
    D:Caneira
    D:Miguel
    D:Pepe
    D:Nelson
    D:Abel
    GK:Ricardo
    GK:R.Patricio

  • Matt, Canada
    13/04/2008 23:32
    that no name was me sorry
  • ,
    13/04/2008 23:32
    First Choice:

    ST:Nuno Gomes(c)
    CAM:C.Ronaldo
    LWM:Simao Sabrosa
    LCM:Deco
    RCM:Joao Moutinho
    RWM:R.Quaresma
    LB:P.Ferreira
    CB:R.Carvalho
    CB:F.Meira
    RB:Bosingwa
    GK:Quim

    Second Choice:

    ST:Hugo Almeida
    CAM:Deco
    LWM:R.Quaresma
    LCM:Tiago
    RCM:Joao Moutinho
    RWM:C.Ronaldo(c)
    LB:P.Ferreira
    CB:R.Carvalho
    CB:B.Alves
    RB:Miguel
    GK:Ricardo

    Which one is better for you???
  • matt, canada
    13/04/2008 23:15
    Im sorry to say this: Tony i agree with you with the 100 percent Portuguese thing and i do believe Deco is one of the best players on that team, but one thing i don't agree with you is will he be able to change his game during Euro 2008 last time i checked major competitions were not training grounds for trying players that haven't been playing well all season.Now with Nani i dont think hes better then Simao atleast not now Nani is good but not good enough to start for portugal we need smart players not ones that sometimes dont no what to do with the ball hes good but not better then Simao right now i could see if it was the World Cup in 2010 he will be starting then but not now like ive said before.Whats wrong with puting Ronaldo in the attacking role for Portugal he seems to be doing that for his club and hes scoring tons of goals, this gives room for Quaresma and Simao to come in.O the Ribeiro thing i made a mistake lol i ment P.Ferreira.Ricardo sucks he doesnt start for Real Betis so why should we play him , on the other hand i dont want to see Quim starting but hes are best choice hes experienced for Benfica why not give it a try better then a mistake with Ricardo. But i do like the fact you introduced Tiago your right he is a better choice over Maniche and of course Raul hes a good player. Heres my New Line up comment on it..

  • Tony Lima, Marysville, CA USA
    13/04/2008 22:31
    Matt: not sure I agree with your logic that you don't start players who are not starting for their clubs. Also, don't agree if they are not of Portuguese orgin they should not start over 100% Portuguese. If they are better they shold start in my opinion.

    Just because a player starts for a one club doesn't mean that they are better than the player not starting for their club.

    - Deco has been a disappointment lately but he can still recover from injury and perform in Euro 2008.

    - Simao over Nani? Nani is a spot starter and super sub who is recently injured. I've watch the recent ManU games and they could have used him over Park. Is Simao a better player? I think Simao is a good sub for the last 15 minutes of a game. He performs better as a sub by his past national team history
    - Ribeiro should not start -- he is a disaster brewing. I'd but Miguel on the left back.
    - One player who had been disappointing but is in better form is Tiago. Maybe he gets a call up over Maniche, Petit, Mireiles (we agree on Maniche and Mireles).
    - As bad a goalie as Ricardo is you have to give it to him over Quim.
    - I don't think playing CR in some striker/middle role will work. You need to play one of our weak strikers (they are all the same -- it doesn't matter who you play)

    Anyway just some thoughts, I know we all care and want to see the best team out there. All in good fun. Cheers!

  • Alec, Amsterdam
    11/04/2008 20:33
    Mister Aizawl Vdhazer from India, Orlandomac and Ramos from Toronto,

    Thank you very much for your expertise and kind and swift replies.

    If you'd have any questions about Amsterdam or my expertise (energy), please let me know.

    Alec
  • matt, canada
    10/04/2008 21:37
    First we can't play players that haven't started for there club for ex Deco,Maniche,Ricardo,Nani.

    My line will have players that have been starters for there own club.

    ST:Nuno Gomes (c)
    CAM:Ronaldo
    RWM:Ricardo Quaresma
    LWM:Simao Sabrosa
    LCM:Miguel Veloso
    RCM:Joao Moutinho
    LB:Jorge Ribeiro
    LCB:Ricardo Carvalho
    RCB:Fernando Meira
    RB: Bosingwa
    GK: Quim

    Players like Hugo Almeida can come on as a super sub as we have seen against greece paired up with Nuno Gomes up front.Nani can sub in for Simao Sabrosa. Deco,Pepe can be subs because they aren't Portuguese Born Players and they do not have the right to take 100% pure portuguese players Positions.
    Miguel is exellent on the right side for the attack and defence he can come on as a later sub for Bosingwa. Caneira is sub because he isnt all that great,Ricardo hasn't started for Betis so no point on trying him, so this is were Quim comes in with tons of exp for Benfica. Maniche can't score and doesn't start for inter.
    Bruno Alves probably has just as good of a chance of playing the CB role with Carvalho or Meira which i wouldn't mind seeing because hes and exeptional talent. Nani shouldn't start because hes to young and doesnt start for united we shouldn't use the national team for getting nani exp leave that for united. Players like:
    Meireles,C.Martins,Makukula SHOULDN'T BE ON THE NATIONAL TEAM THEY ARE HORRIBLE AND TAKE UP OTHER PLAYERS SPACE ON THE TEAM.
  • Fernando, Canada
    08/04/2008 16:34
    Rob,
    Of all of the line-ups that have been presented I would have to say that your roster makes the most sense. Although I am concerned with a lack of grit in the middle of the park, I would like to see Moutinho in the middle with Deco and Veloso. Also, I would prefer Nani over Simao-give him as much experience as possible. Almeida isn't playing much right now in Germany but it's not like we have a whole bunch of options up front. I would love to see this squad in our next friendly.

    Forca Portugal
  • Rob, Montreal ,Canada
    07/04/2008 21:04
    This is my starting line up and reserve squad to bring to the euro.

    gk Ricardo
    lb Ribeiro
    rb bosingwa
    cb Carvalho
    cb Pepe
    mf Veloso
    mf Moutinho
    mf Deco
    lw Simao
    rw Ronaldo
    st Almeida

    PATRICIO
    QUIM
    ALVES
    MEIRA
    MIGUEL
    CANEIRA
    FERREIRA
    MANICHE
    MEREILES
    MARTINS
    PETIT
    NANI
    QUERESMA
    GOMES
    MAKUKULA

    This team is poised for something grat i ca feel it.Don't let these nothing games throw you off,they want to win a cup and they can.Scolari knows how to get them going,and if they start to click as a real team watch out.I really think what we are missing is Moutinho playing with Deco.Deco can't do it alone just with Maniche or a Tiago they were both less offensivly gifted then Moutinho and that will create chances for everyone.Remember that game vs Brazil thats who we had together!Beleive in PORTUGAL!
  • Vdhazer, Aizawl, India
    05/04/2008 11:32
    I will help you wiht this:
    http://www.ee.oulu.fi/~msp/tmp/Costinha_PetitePauleta.jpg

    The person on the right is Pauleta (PSG #9), middle is Nuno Valente (Everton #19), and the left is Hugo Viana (Osasuna loan #20).

    I hope your friend will be happy.
  • CARLOS RAMOS, AUSTRALIA
    04/04/2008 09:51
    my team for euro 2008 gk quim rb miguel cb r carvalho cb meira p ferreira mf dani mf deco mf maniche mf quaresma cf cristiano ronaldo cf nuno gomes
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    03/04/2008 22:34
    You are a good man to chase that info for your ex...

  • ramos, toronto, canada
    03/04/2008 17:24
    nuno valente
  • Alec, Amsterdam, Netherlands
    03/04/2008 13:20
    Petit does not appear to be the one she's after. It's the guy in the middle on this pricture.
    http://www.ee.oulu.fi/~msp/tmp/Costinha_PetitePauleta.jpg
    Who knows his name (and number:-).

    Cheers in advance,
    Alec
  • Alec, Amsterdam, Netherlands
    03/04/2008 11:39
    Hi guys,

    Loox like there're some experts here that can help me out on this one.

    A friend of mine has a crush on Portugal's new defender Petite. Does this guy have a website, are there any pictures of him or does anyone know his full name?

    Cheers in advance,
    Alec

    PS. Why am I doing this anyway? I hate these vain knife-grinders (since our last game against them). Well it's for my son's mother. We split up a long time ago, but she likes football (players).
  • Vdhazer, Aizawl, India
    31/03/2008 08:58
    This is from the mind of a football genius, what the formation should be:

    Ricardo – GK
    Carvalho – CB
    Meira – CB
    Bosingwa – LB
    Miguel – RB
    Deco – CM
    Maniche - CM
    Miguel Veloso – CDM
    Ronaldo – RWF
    Quaresma – LW
    Nuno Gomes – ST

    With this formation, they can’t lose.
  • Vdhazer, Aizawl, India
    31/03/2008 08:48
    The shame of loosing again at the hands of Greece again is too much. I was hoping that without the likes of Ronaldo, Nani, Bosingwa, Deco, and Maniche, they would have no problem to bit Greece now with the superb form of Quaresma, Hugo Almeida, and others of Simao etc. But it is once again shocking, yet humiliating to be defeated by Greece after the unforgettable Euro 2004. From the next preparation game, this is personal, there should be no count out for the best player in the world Ronaldo and also with the likes of Nani and Deco. So, from the next game, this will be set clear. I am certain and I believe that Scolari will make the best decision for the match, not resting any key players. So, I can well said that from the next match, things will be set clear.
  • matthew, canada
    29/03/2008 15:17

    ST:Nuno Gomes (C)
    CAM:C.Ronaldo
    LWM:Simao Sabrosa
    LCM:F.Meira
    RCM:Deco
    RWM:Joao Moutinho
    LB:P.Ferreira
    LCB:R.Carvalho
    RCB:Pepe
    RB:Luis Miguel
    GK:Eduardo

    Subs:
    ST:Hugo Almeida
    ST:Helder Postiga
    CAM:Maniche
    LWM:Nani
    RWM:Ricardo Quaresma
    CM:Miguel Veloso
    CM:C.Martins
    LB:Caneira
    RB:Boswinga
    LB:Jorge Ribeiro
    CB:Bruno Alves
    GK:Ricardo

    Left Corner: Deco
    Right Corner:Deco
    Direct Free Kick:Ronaldo,Simao or Deco depends on situation or postion
    Indirect Free Kick: Deco or Simao
    Penalties: Simao Sabrosa
  • Ramos, toronto, canada
    29/03/2008 13:35
    not at all impressed by Pepe, Meira looks lost out there, Gomes is past his prime. And I think we be better off playing Miguel or Bosingwa instead of Ferreria in the lb role. Also I would start Nani ahead of Simao. Here's my lineup

    Almeida (st)
    Ronaldo (rwm)
    Deco (cam)
    Nani (lwm)
    Veloso (cdm)
    Maniche* (cdm)
    Bosignwa (LB)
    Carvalho (CB)
    Meira (CB)
    Miguel (RB)
    Ricardo (GK)

  • matt, canada
    27/03/2008 00:35
    my line up vs georgia....

    ST:NunoGomes ( C )
    CAM:Ronaldo
    LWM:Simao
    RWM:Moutinho
    LCM:Meira
    RCM:Deco
    LB:Ferreira
    LCB:Carvalho
    RCB:Pepe
    RB:Miguel
    GK:Patricio

    Subs:
    Hugo Almeida
    Makukula
    Quaresma
    Nani
    Veloso
    Maniche
    Martins
    Caneira
    J.Ribeiro
    B.Alves
    Bosingwa
    Ricardo

    There lol we better beat GEORGIA IF WE DONT THEN SCREW EUROPE
  • matt, canada
    27/03/2008 00:24
    lol that comment was me and im right portugal is shit we play horrible gomes was the star as well with meira,ferreira,miguel,pepe,carvalho thats it caniera is shit ricardo is shit meireles is shit martins is shit o and moutinho was a star vs greece and quaresma was playing horrible and simao was injured so we suck
  • ,
    27/03/2008 00:22
    portugal is shit
  • Kevin Ramos, toronto, canada
    26/03/2008 23:23
    I don't care if this a friendly and we're experimenting with our formation. I hate losing to Greece they're absolute garbage and its an embarassment that we continue to lose to them.
  • Tony Lima, Marysville, CA USA
    26/03/2008 22:33
    Orlandomac, I saw some of the game during lunch. Enough to get a feel for the game. I know this forum is for forward play but a few comments:

    1) Portugal is once again susceptible to give up goals off dead ball situations. Most of the goals we have given up recently are indirect/direct or corner goals. We made fouls to give Greece opportunities.
    2) Ferreira and Caniera I agree on this. These guys make too many mistakes and unsettle the defense. We need to find a way to get Boswinga and Miguel on the field (right back and left back)
    3) Our attacking play once again was lacking of crip passing. Quar was awful. We never got into a good flow and I suppose Greece has some to do with that but some of the bad passes were unforced in my opinion. Seem like the playes have not gotten used to playing together.
    4) Almeida and Gomes might have done well upfront in the last 20 minutes but I'm not convinced this is an ideal combo -- maybe in the last few minutes of a game.
    5) Conclusion, a friendly and experimental game that may help
    Scolari draw conclusions. Lots of work left to do but lets get certain players off the field (point #2), cut down on the stupid fouls that lead to deadball situations where we are weak, and hope that are mids and attack can get it together in the summer for 3-4 weeks. Sometimes its best to peak late and not too early. I'll be happy getting out of the first round at this point.
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    26/03/2008 22:04
    I agree with the comments all you gentlemen have made, yes it is true our strikers are not wanted by other teams, & Ricardo hasn't cost us huge actually he has performed very admirably in the tournies.

    This discussion though is mostly about the forward position and which way is best going forward for Scolari so I will save my comments for later discussions in those areas.

    Now I didn't catch the start today as I work nights & was chasing a former UFC & MW champ for an interview yesterday.
    But Joe I still feel like the others that the service is poor.
    But of the last 25 mins that I watched Gomes looked good and linked up well with Almeida. Ribeiro & Miguel played well, but it looked unspectacular. I always knew these two games against Italy and Greece were not going to turn out well. Both play solid as a unit & can show the holes our players have with their individualistic play.
    But it is a great slap to the face for the squad, and is a positive, better to lose now when the games are meaningless then to have the same approach during the Euro.
    Ricardo
    Ferreira
    Caneira
    Meira
    Simão
    Pepe
    Carvalho
    Nuno Gomes
    Quaresma
    Carlos Martins
    Veloso
    The biggest problem I see with that selection is the FB's Caneira & Ferreira can make allot of mistakes and unsettle a D because of their lack of foot speed on the wings.
    Now I didn't see enough of the game to have a opinion but will watch the replay as soon as I get a chance.
    What do you guys think?
  • Sevenman, Kitchener, Canada
    25/03/2008 04:11
    No probs with Portugal on def and at midfield, they're solid players at all those spots ( including goal)....the problems, I think, are upfront and it's not with the talent because Portugal has plenty....it's the inability to create enough scoring chances to produce enough goals to win enough games. Too often over the years, there seems to be selfishness on the national team for some reason ( think everyone wants to be the hero, can't blame 'em )..... but more ball movement= more chances= more goals. I'm also afraid that this team might be lacking a bit in the leadership department. Having said all that, can't wait for this summer... like our chances of getting out of the first round, after that, who knows?


    problems I trhink indiv
  • Mark, Toronto
    25/03/2008 00:50
    Simao on the left, Qboy on the right and CRon in the middle supporting Maku, Almeida or Gomes. Simao has experience and plays very well on the left as he enjoys cutting into the middle. He has had many solid games for the NT and his experince is an asset. Qboy simply because of his trickery and his ability to frustrate players. Cron in the middle because he is tall (perfect for crosses) and has both sides of the field to run and distribute to and will probably open space on the wings which will be great for our wingers. Nani is a close second and could be a super sub. We do not have a bonafie striker but my choice would be almeida.

    Martins is a good selection because he has been on fire for Huelva and has been the best player on the field many games for either team. He is strong, quick, has good vision and a bomba for a shot.
  • al, perth
    24/03/2008 22:11
    1 thing is 4 sure ricardo sucks quim is the best
  • matt, canada
    24/03/2008 20:47
    this is good for portugal now we need to try other players and taking ronaldo out of the squad will help our newer players to shine
  • Joe, NJ USA
    24/03/2008 20:41
    Orlando, you are a great fan and your knowledge of soccer and the National team is second to none. I enjoy all your posts.

    But I must disagree. You said that the weakest positions on the team are the Goal Keeper & Defensive Mid. No way. Our weakest position by far is the centre forward position.

    Ricardo is not a world class goalie, never has been, and he has been starting on the national team when others have been more deserving. But how many games has Ricardo cost us??? What big game did we lose where we could place the blame on Ricardo? On the contrary, how many HUGE games did we win where he deserves some of the credit? I think quite a few. No he is not great, but he is not the reason we have not won a title, and thus not a weakness.

    Defensive mid when we had Costinha and or more recently with Petite hasn't been terrible. Though this is more of a weakspot I think than the keeper position, I think Petite has done an admirable job and Meira can fit in well here as well.

    Our problem is GOALS. We lose games 1-0, we tie games 0-0, 1-1. Our problem is goals from the centre forward position. Mak, Almeida, (and esp. Gomes) only score when the ball is perfectly fed. These players do not create chances on their own. I've said it before and I'll say it again, none of our centre forwards (Gomes, Mak, Almedia, Postiga) would even smell the field on any other major national team. Period. But they're the best we got (and, our major weakness).

  • Tony LIma, Marysville, CA USA
    24/03/2008 18:51
    Orlandomac, I agree with you in general and we can consider our wings a mids -- I have no problem. We agree that we have no #10 and now we are giving Martins a shot. I just hope Deco can stay healthy and play well for about 5-6 games in the summer but we'll need a longer term solution for 2010. If you find him somewhere let me. I still don't like our other 2 mids with the exception of Veloso.

    I don't disagree that the service is lacking for our strikers but they are still not wanted by major clubs. I'm not sold on Almeida even with a decetn rate on Werder he is not seen in great esteem. I would prefer Postiga. Gomes can be good to come off the bench for 20 minutes and he as scored big goals for Portugal. I think one reason (not all the reasons) for lack of service is that our wingers don't have much confidence in the stikers. You see Quar and RC build up distand rapport with strikers on their clubs but never have been able to sync up at national level. Lets keep the faith and passion going and maybe one day in our lifetime we'll see striker close to Eusebio (60% will do). I agree 100% with you on Pauletta, he profited from the soccer minnows of eastern Europe.
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    24/03/2008 05:11
    Tony I can appreciate that we have some weaknesses but Portugal is not weak at midfield we are the best in the world at mid period. Those wingers although some consider Forwards are actual mids we just don't have a number ten at the moment that is playing well unless Carlos Martins proves me wrong, which he just might do.
    As for striker like I said everyone goes on about this but if you have a closer look their service is very poor. Only Nani is a good crosser and our wingers are very selfish. They choose to run and shoot 9 out of 10 times even when double marked.
    I will stand to defend the lone strikers as a courtesy here as Hugo Almeida when I checked a week ago had 8 Goals for Werder in 15 games not too shabby. Mak has been injured, Postiga is 33% for Portugal, and Nuno Gomes has 27 goals off the bench and will make for a great super sub as he has scored some vital goals.
    Although I wasn't a big fan of Pauleta mostly for his record of scoring against top notch opponents but even I will admit that his service was very poor. I believe the weakest positions on the team are the Goal Keeper & Defensive Mid.. I feel at all other areas we have depth. I think this tournament we will be a good one for our strikers, because I feel they will get more service than in the past.
  • Tony Lima, Marysville, CA 95901
    23/03/2008 22:00
    Scolari's style of play can be ugly but it has been effective. I think Scolari will do a good job in Euro 2008 and have the team ready to play. Too many people are quick to think Mourinho is a savior and everything will be better with him coaching. Perhaps we'll play with more style -- come on, that is not realistic. I doubt based on his history and the weaknesses we have,

    he would do that. We can't play with too much style when you don't have a world class striker up front. Also, mentioned weakness in the midfield. You have to keep the games close and hope your wingers can do something to score 1 or 2 goals plus play tight in the back. If If I was coaching this team, I would do exactly what Scolari is doing.

    On the attacking options up front, whatever plan we come up with should allow for Quar, Nani, and CR to be on the field together. They are the best 3 offensive players Portugal currently has. Maybe our best striker option is the huge bust Postiga, he can have stretches where he is good for 3-4 games out of the year. He might be offer the most trouble up front for a defense. If he continues to perform well, I might throw him in. I think Makakula is out and is not a viable option. Maybe Nuno Gomes will find magic for a few games but he too is washed up. Difficult to coach when you have some limitations at certain positions.
  • Ramos, toronto, canada
    23/03/2008 13:06
    You better believe we'll shut down toronto when we win some games at euro. To call Gama and Concetrao busts before they even establish themselves is a bit premature. We have depth in spades on the wing and in central defence where we need the most help is in the middle of the field this is where we can be exploited. Scolari's style of coaching bugs me, he wins ugly, but I can't argue with the man's record. However I would love to see Mourinho take over after this tournament which I think is a distinct possibility.
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    21/03/2008 18:43
    Tony I agree with everything you said.. I realize this team has allot of work to do yet.. LOTS.. I have an article that I wrote here on the reasons why Portugal won't win and I completely dissect every player.. but it was too long to post. I based this one on trying to pick the best team.
    There is definitely allot of potential on the team but like I said agree completely with everything you said albeit it still might be early on Gama & Coentrao they still have allot to prove as well.
    We are a spirited and passionate bunch aren't we.. this tournament like PSousa said and I believe as well is the most difficult, any slip up could be the end. With all the youngsters on the Team I still think we have allot of time to reap some rewards but it will require them to play as a unit. That is still questionable but I love the game immensely especially during the WC and the Euro. The streets are alive here in Toronto.. if Portugal wins some games they will shut down the center of Toronto with all the traffic.. the b
  • Tony Lima, Marysville, CA USA
    21/03/2008 16:54
    I wanted to agree with PSousa on his comments about keeping things in perspective on Portuguese soccer talent. We all have passion and want to see Portugal have success but we must be objective. For one single talent Portugal produces that is successful (e.g. CR) we have 5 busts (Viana, Postiga, etc.).
    Orlandomac sounds like a good guy and knows soccer but thinking that Portugal has riches coming up is a bit over optimistic. Look at the showings in U-17 to U-20 in the past few years. There are a few players with promise but players like Gama and Coentrao that he mentions have shown to be busts and I predict will be busts.

    Our current national roster is good but flawed, let me provide an analysis:
    1) We have strikers no one wants.
    2) Great winger player (CR, Quar, Nani, and even Simao)
    3) Deco is the only creative midfielder. Joao Moutino has not proven he is that player. Now they are trying Carlos Martins
    4) Rest of midfield: Veloso looks like he has potentail and is one of the most promisi
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    20/03/2008 15:26
    "Captain Ronaldo takes another step towards legendary status"

    These are not my words as you might have read the press clippings on the main page Mr. Sousa you are running out of people on the list.. Cruyff now Best not many left.. on your list.. I am not his biggest fan I am actually very critical of CR.. ask anyone that knows me.. but Cristiano at 23 looks like a sure bet to pass everyone but Pele on your list.. now if he could add a few trophies to his reign their would be no conversation.. but I am the prejudiced fan..
    Being a critic I have realized that constraining CR to play a sounder game is not the answer.. the answer is to give him a bigger stage to shine on.. after much contemplation I came upon the Maestro role.. the Midfield Maestro.
    Will Portugal discover Total Football I doubt it.. as too many personalities want the limelight and bigger contracts. But if you can challenge them to be the Maestro which means assists more than goals and all 3 forwards compete for that role then I believe
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    20/03/2008 11:30
    Then you conveniently compare all the plyrs in the 20+ yrs that JC played with the 6 yrs of CR choosing the youngest & least accomplished in comparison.
    Ronaldo has scored more goals than anyone ever for Brazil and has as many WC's as any. Ronaldinho too is there; Zinedine Zidane 1 WC 1Euro they pulled the double; add Henry there too; Roberto Carlos; Figo; Maldini; & Pauleta, etc.

    For any that know me the last one was a joke but nonetheless he has more goals than Eusebio. Now those are the guys that CR has been around in only 6 yrs call me in 15 yrs to make that comparison fair lol

    I can appreciate that you've read & watched a few games; as have I but there is some truth and merit to your argument, and I say yours because it is all yours. This is banter for me and am quite enjoying it, within reason.
    I can also appreciate that you are a purest and prefer a set game. As a fan I too can appreciate the past but also understand that beyond the speculation that you talk about with the best ever, todays
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    20/03/2008 10:27
    PSousa dude you make me laugh.. I mean this in a nice way. You say I twist things to suit my need as you twirl like a ballarina. I never said Ronaldo was better than Cruyff yet, just that he had surpassed his tournie record which he has at the age of 23. Could he surpass Cruyff as a player? The possibility is definitely there, if you can't see that then I have to question your self proclaimed knowledge. Besides National wise he is already 5 goals shy of Cruyff's all time best for the Dutch so I can't imagine it would be that difficult considering CR has got at least 5 Tournies left in him bar major injuries.
    Then you go on about how poor Maniche & Costinha are neglecting the fact that they were crowned champs in two most prestigious club tournies in the world 7 were very important cogs.
    Then you ask me to refute my own claim of the 10's of millions of porks dude that is your job to do, would you like me to diddle your girl too when you are tired? kidding lol
    As for the squad you said this was no time
  • matt, canada
    20/03/2008 01:16
    GK: Ricardo
    RB:Miguel
    CB:Carvalho
    CB:Pepe
    RB:Ribeiro
    RM:Quaresma
    RCM:Martins
    LCM:Veloso
    LM:Nani
    CAM:Ronaldo
    ST:NunoGomes

    Meira(Veloso or Martins)
    Moutinho(Veloso or Martins)
    Simao(Nani)
    Alves(Carvalho or Pepe)
    Caneira(Ribeiro)
    Ferreira(Miguel)
    Almeida(Gomes)

    That should do the job for Portugal against Greece i think its gonna be 2-0 for Portugal if all goes well : D!!!!!
  • PSousaNJ,
    19/03/2008 22:36
    ryan....thats a retarded lineup........caneira instead of bosingwa lol ok.....carlos martins n simao as center mids???????? do you watch soccer?.......i thought nuno gomes was in a wheelchair at this point......i dont mean to be a hater but wow that was mighty stupid.....
  • PSousaNJ, Newark,NJ,USA
    19/03/2008 20:53
    lol....thats really funny i like how you twist things to fit your arguement....and put words in my mouth whoever said aything about Malta??? you did....i was refering to countries like holland and the czech republic.....# 2 you cant buy players for the national team you gotta pick from a pool so i dunno how well hell do with a. pinto da costa making all the right moves or b. roman abramovichs money........and we have 10s of millions abroad?? lol thats a bit of a stretch YOU SHOW ME thats a fact and not some number you made up......and wait i didnt know you had a direct line to scolari and told him to field YOUR lineup lol im pretty sure he can handle that on his own after how many world cups have YOU won?....and to the main point...1 final??? hmm thats more than Ronaldo isnt it???what has ronaldo won???and you stated that hes top 3 with a bunch of legendary players behind him??? wrong....Messi KaKa n Henry legendery yes....lets look at Cruyffs era shall we.Beckenbauer,Rivilino,Pele,Blokhin,Zico,Zoff,Muller,
  • Ryan, Fall River, US
    19/03/2008 19:55
    I think Portugal need to attack Greece to start the game, they need to go right at them! play the 4-3-3:

    GK:Ricardo

    RB:Miguel
    CB:Ricardo Carvalho
    Bruno Alves
    LB:Caneira

    LCM:Simao
    CM:Deco
    RCM:Carlos Martins

    RW:C.Ronaldo
    ST:Nuno Gomes (C)
    LW:Quaresma

    Quaresma is in great form right now. He's played tremendously good since the Friendly against Italy.
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    19/03/2008 11:02
    Also as for your assertions that we are a tiny country.. you continue to neglect the fact that we have 10's of millions if not more abroad.. as you and I are testiment too.. I know in the Toronto area alone there is close to a million Porkchops.. and we aren't even near the top of the food chain for transplanted Porks.
    If you didn't notice others have as Canada has supplied a few players alredy to the national squads youth teams.. and more are on the way I assure you. So don't compare us to Malta as we have a much larger and populated history of explorers.
    He opinions are like elbows everyone has one a couple. Hey the debate is great but if you are going to make assertions than back it up with proof because all the facts point against your theory. Besides I am not inventing the wheel as you said it has already been done. As for my lineup and my system Scolari has already fielded my whole squad in it's entirety. Fortunately for us Scolari's tournies far exceed his qualifying record, but even a blind m
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    19/03/2008 10:50
    PSousa clearly it is you who is showing the bias if Cruyff was such a good player than why did his total team win nothing. He was in one final that was it & without him the Dutch went to the next final. Total team nothing. I have watched the majority of Man U matches this year, and the players switch repeatedly that is what makes them so successful don't tell me you haven't seen Rooney running down the wings either because then you missed last weeks highlights. As we speak CR has already surpassed Cruyff those are the facts. He is 23 years of age. Right now he is classified as at worst top 3 in the world with some fantastic players behind him that will rank in the best of the best ever. So reality states that we have thee best player in the whole tournament we also have some of the most highly sought after players in the world all around him, would you like some more realism.
    How about the fact that those lousy players that you claim Stupidlari had to carry also happened to win the Uefa Championship and t
  • PSousaNJ, Newark,NJ,USA
    19/03/2008 02:07
    i also want to add that as portuguese people or fans of the team we need to stop overrating our players (ie "the golden generation") all that does is put pressure and expectations on players that alot of times arent warented we are a country of barely 10 million and to do what weve done so far is a great achievement lets be realistic about our talent and not go the way of the english and spanish who do exactly what i mentioned before...lets keep things in perspective people a great fan/supporter is a realistic one....
  • PSousaNJ, Newark,NJ,USA
    18/03/2008 16:53
    im sorry orlandomac but your biased is shinning through Johan Cruyff was the most complete soccer player ever to play the game the total football system was invented for him and ended with him......as for ronaldo playing a support role for man u i dunno what games ur watching but thats wayne rooneys position on the field it may seem like ronaldo is playing a supporting striker role but in fact hes playing wide forward position not a supporting striker he just tends to cut inside when near the box....in fact man u does not play with a true striker most times as tevez n rooney are both naturally suppport strikers lets not try to reinvent the wheel here and the euro cup is not a time to experiment unless you whant to be embarresed like in 2002....scolari knows what hes doing hes shown me that by taking as to semi final and finals of major tournamets beating our rivals(spain,england)and getting the most out of a team with a midfield that consisted of maniche and costinha and pauleta up front...the only mistake h
  • Ricardo Costa, S.J. da Madeira, Portugal
    18/03/2008 12:36
    Hey Well I agree and disagree with many of you but what i believe is that if Portugal wants to play well they need a good 10 player that can supply the forwards. Deco hasn't been playing well and with a 10 they don't work together well. I like the idea of Ronaldo in the center play the 10 but he poses more of a threat on the wings...... if deco could step up as the 10 then i would have him behind the 3 forwards of almeida nani and ronaldo......... NANI has got to play he is playing unbelievably good at the moment with little playing time!!! and Scolari has got to bring the hunger back into the squad... they don't have the fast drive they had before!!!!

    But we'll see how they play in greece....... Even though we played bad against italy..scolari also was testing out new tactics with them..... but they still have to improve!!

    I love Portugal

    Good Luck!!
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    18/03/2008 02:09
    PSousa that wasn't my lineup that was what I believed Scolari to start for the Euro.. as I still have to list it all for the fine people here I will not comment so much.. just to say that I agree with your assessment of Caneira.

    As for your comments on Johan Cruyff.. I think great players of CR's magnitude should be allowed to create their artwork and sometimes we should think outside the box. As for this role being a new one.. it is not much different than the role he plays for Man U as for the most part he is not a winger for Man U. Almost all his goals have come from the middle as a support striker (forward).

    All I ask more is that he assist more in Almeida's success. Being older I have watched allot of ball I personally don't think you are correct in your assertion Cruyff will never be a Ronaldo as it stands they are slightly even as both never won a trophy for their nation but I believe that Ronaldo will win a Trophy for as Quinas.

    To a certain extent you are correct Cristiano Ronaldo is no
  • PSousaNJ, Newark,NJ,USA
    17/03/2008 17:49
    A.Mourinho coudlnt have stated it any better my friend.....and orloandomac please stop trying to create new postions for players....ronaldo is a wiger he needs the soace for his runs and to dribble...he is not johan cruyff.....
  • PSousaNJ, Newark,NJ,USA
    17/03/2008 17:44
    i agree with orlandos line up completely meira will always stay back and cover wich allows bos n miguel to push up more freely and allows veloso to move up into attack and distribute to the wings which is what he does best as well as ball control which is the cms role....i feel this will be the lineup with one exception.....Caneira??? come on please he gets burned constantly he has no recovery speed and is weak on the attack wich would leave the LM alone on the wing like he did in the italy friendly we need miguel n bos on the wings with quaresma and ronaldo all 4 can interchange sides and that is a scary thought....other than the caneria error the lineup is perfect and to me top 3 in the world....only two weaknesses goalie n fw.....
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    17/03/2008 12:08
    Matt I thought they would think I went overboard with 4 FW's but my plan was part of a free floating system of attack & defense. I have solidified my defenders so that our forwards could attack well.

    I believe a good deal of your realistic dose has merit.

    This was the same for the Golden Gen too many individualistic players who waited till they matured before they started 2 share the ball. Its the mgrs job to instill this, CR does so well at Man U because of the meat & potato guys he has around him. The likes of CR,Q,N,& S have to learn to share the ball to gain space and to become unstoppable. I feel that's why we should partner them all up now with some decent strikers because it will pay off within the next two tourneys.
    We've learned that solid defensive teams such as France, Italy, & Greece dismantle our team because they make it easy for the other team to double mark them and shut down the individuals. In a way that is my reasoning the defenses can't double up on them all someone will be fre
  • matt, canada
    17/03/2008 00:06
    If we think its gonna be a walk in the park in Euro 2008 well your dreaming we were lucky we weren't stuck with Holland and France or even Italy as well that would of been no point of Showing up we would of been destroyed and embaressed.

    The way we are heading we won't win a game in 2008 unless we change our ways.

    We got Greece next ??? are we gonna lose horribly like we did against italy or hope Greece doesnt score and tie them like finland???

    We then got Georgia??? if we tie them then we aren't a good team even though we have some of the best players in the world. We might as well be called the crapiest teams in europe along with San Marino and lativa just to name a few.

    Portugal better find there game. Since the game against Belguim and Brazil or even the World Cup we have been playing horrible we are lucky to be ranked 8th in the World and in 2008 what if we had to face Poland or Serbia instead of Armenia or any of the crap teams or what about Poland instead of Finland for the last game wo
  • matt, canada
    16/03/2008 23:46
    First lets look at portugal overall in qualifing and the 2 past friendlies vs italy and brazil and the upcoming ones.

    How did portugal do in euro 2008 qualifing too me they could of done much better.

    when you face teams like azerbaijan, kazakshtan and armenia we should barley beat them the first time we faced azer and kazak we beat them 3-0 each i believe the last time we faced them we struggled to even score we beat azer 2-0 and kazak 2-1 and we tied armenia 1-1 the first time and only scored one goal the last time now theres a problem.

    Now finland,serbia and belguim there most likely just as bad as armenia, azerbaijan and kazakshtan but still we strugled to beat them we teid finland 1-1 the first time and 0-0 the second time???? what??? how???? and tied serbia both times i believe???? AGAIN WHAT???? and we beat belguim 4-0 the first time and thats the way it should be vs the the weak teams of the group then we almost tied them the second time we won because helder postiga got that lucky goal whic
  • matt, canada
    16/03/2008 23:29
    how am i crazy ablerto im sorry to say this but im not crazy.

    what would you have done nuno gomes alone as the striker who can't score or hugo almeida and makukula who are big guys and can score????

    Wouldn't you want nani, c.ronaldo and quaresma together well the coach does and scoring goals is the first thing portugal needs to do we need to score atleast 2 or 3 goals in order to win then we concentrate on defense because our defence isnt the greatest and definitly the keeping

    before the world cup 2006 portugal could score goals like nothing but when we came to 2006 we couldnt even score against iran,angola and mexico we should of beaten angola 4-0 atleast and iran 5-0 atleast get real here thats why we lost to france and barely beat england and got killed by the hosts we couldnt scored and that resulted in losing ,the thing about portugal is they pass to much i no thats a good idea when it comes to defence , but when were done 1 or 2 goals done we cant score. we just hope the other team doesnt s
  • Alberto Mourinho, Lisbon, Portugal
    16/03/2008 22:54
    Fantastic feedback guys. Really interesting comments, great points made and well argued. Hey Orlando! We agree on lots but not everything! It seems Quaresma is yet to "earn" his place for most people and also most of you say Nani should start.

    Like I said, I'm a diehard Benfica fan, so I am in no way biased, and I have to say that Quaresma deserves to be playing for Portugal from the start now. Sure, he infuriates us by losing the ball a lot, but then he makes a perfect assist or scores a brilliant goal to decide the match.

    Remember against Kazakhstan? It was exactly what happened. It was 0-0 with little time left, Quaresma hadn't played well, but all of a sudden he did a bit of manage and set up a goal Makukula couldn't miss and Portugal won. Remember if we hadn't won that game we wouldn't be at the Euro!

    Nani will be a great player for club and country in the future I am sure, but he still needs to learn. That's why Alex Ferguson leaves him out of the Man U side a lot. He has a huge role
  • matt, canada
    16/03/2008 21:34
    my line up is a 2-1-3-4 formation with makukula and almeida pairing up front and c.ronaldo behind them for support then i would have nani on the left because his performance for man u is exellant then quaresma on the right wing and deco as the center mid role with antunes as the left back with carvalho and pepe as center backs and miguel as the right back with beto as keeper. my subs would be nuno gomes subing either almeida or makukula then joao moutinho subing ronaldo if needed even though it would be unlikely then simao could sub nani and ronaldo could move to the right wing if quaresma needed to be subed with moutinho taking ronaldos place then i would have veloso take decos postion as a sub then caneira for antunes and bruno alves for pepe or carvalho and bosingwa for miguel and ricardo for beto
  • Pedro,
    15/03/2008 18:11
    I agree with Alberto about Simao. He's never done it for Portugal aside from the very odd flash. I wouldn't consider him for the starting eleven. I actually don't think Quaresma can be relied on either. For me Nani has shown the most this season and he should get the other flank position. Ronaldo, Nani and Deco behind Almeida = European champions.
  • Vdhazer, Aizawl, India
    15/03/2008 11:39
    Having one of the best player in the world undoubtedly Ronaldo, Portugal with do great in the coming European Championship. With the likes of Ronaldo, Quaresma, Simao, and Nani in the wing, these players is will drive the country into high position in the tournament. A much needed strike force in the team, with the upcoming striker Hugo Almeida they have all the quality to go on to the final and with it. Lots of promising uprising stars in the country, Scolari need to give full concentration for whom to select and not to select. With few matches before the tournament start, Scolari needs to give birth to promising players for the big match, who can be of use in the tournament and to just for sitting in the bench.
  • Victor, Toronto, Canada
    15/03/2008 02:19
    It all depends on who we play come match day. Play your strengths, what a player excels in. The choice of subs are decided depending on how the match is going. If we are down I like Gomes in at the 75min. But we need two in the front. Without two in the front the opposing defence won't open up and give chances to our Midfielders. It's the same old every game. They cross in a ball and one striker is sitting there hoping to win it against two defenders. WTF. We can't rely on set pieces every game.
  • Vasco, Toronto
    15/03/2008 01:48
    Fantastic resposnes, but I think Ronaldo is most effective on the wing. The kid excels when he's running down the side and then cutting towards the middle. He operates much in the same way as Henry did when he was at Arsenal. Ronaldo is not as potent as a dropped striker. Always play to your strenghts. Portugal have Almeida, Makukula, N.Gomes and even Postiga (if you get really desperate) as their strikers. What about Joao Paulo as a fourth striker? As for Nani, he's really done well so far in his first year at ManU and deserves a starting spot. Quaresma is an enigma, you never know what you'll get, but if he puts in one or two crosses or hits the ball with the outside of his foot, the game is decided. Simao might have come down the pecking order with Nani's rise, but he's an exceptional player, he really is. Who'll take Deco's place should he get hurt? Moutinho, Tiago, Meireles? As for the back four, Portugal have options with Bosingwa, Miguel, B.Alves, R.Carvalho, Meira, Pepe (I'm not crazy about
  • Victor, Toronto, Canada
    15/03/2008 00:37
    We need two attacking forwards... So many times we play with the single striker and get burned. Give Ronaldo freedom to roam and Miguel to inch up behind on the right flank with those crazy runs he has, not sure if he still has it in him though. Veloso commands the mid D with help from two CB. The defence is the hard part... they need to stop being lazy when at 1-nil.

    Postiga
    Makakula

    Nani Deco Ronaldo
    Veloso(D role)

    Caneira Pepe Meira Miguel
  • matheiu medeiros, deerfield beach, fl
    14/03/2008 20:04
    line-up should go as follows:

    nani, almeida
    quaresma, maniche, deco, ronaldo
    ferreira, meira, carvalho, miquel
  • Ja Toauro, Doha, Qatar
    14/03/2008 11:22
    almeida is not really world class. but since he is strong in the air and could feed off good service, we must keep simao and ronaldo only in the wings. nani is really world class but he needs two more seasons to be really ready but since we don't have many options, we must play him, so the best way to take out the most from him is to play him behind almeida. if almeida fails then we do have an option on the bench....... gomes.... and if at all, god forbids, if bad comes to worse, then ronaldo can take the striker position.

  • paulo goncalves, Australia
    13/03/2008 20:21
    total agree with deco in central mid, nani and ronaldo on the wings (with simao and quaresma coming off bench), hugo almeida and makukula up front...its the best combination..nani is having a great season at man utd.
  • Matt Ferreira, New Jersey, USA
    13/03/2008 20:05
    deco in central mid, nani and ronaldo on the wings (with simao and quaresma coming off bench), hugo almeida and makukula up front
  • ramos, toronto, canada
    13/03/2008 19:42
    Ronaldo and nani should flank the wings, with Almeida in the middle. Deco should be our distributor in the middle of the field. We need ball winners behind these guys if we don't have any ball winners in the middle of the field we are good as done. Our fast and creative wingers tend to lead to turnovers which can only be rectified by strong ball winners in the middle of the field, Fernandes is a great defensive middlefielder, and although he isn't playing that much this season that could be beneficial much like it was for Maniche during world cup 2006.
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    13/03/2008 16:30
    Love the banter guys I believe I have the defensive solution to balance the team but I've promised the fine men at PortuGoal my "Midfield Monsters Lineup" so I will hold back on commenting on that you can read it soon enough.

    Taio you see it like I do Ronaldo being given the freedom to conduct thru the middle *the Maestro* his choice either lead through the middle & supply Almeida or run up into the hole as a support striker or trade on the wings overlapping with Nani or Quaresma it will drive defenses mad.

    Deco has been off his form this year I feel he is a benefit to the team but I weighed that against my 3-1 formation in the end I felt if we go with this youth we will have them around for possibly two more Euro's and 2 WC's that is 5 tournaments altogether so I went with the Fab 4 really we could have many other options.
    I just felt as a team my final formation would be the best and maximize our capabilities.
    I do believe Scolari will start with Deco but as the tournament unravels I believe
  • Taio, UK
    13/03/2008 15:32
    Jonathan, putting Ronaldo central won't stop Scolari from having a midfielder alongside Deco. it would be a 4-2-3-1 formation. i'm not sure who could play in midfield with deco. manny fernandes is not playing much at everton. same with maniche at inter and tiago at juventus. petit is past it in my opinion. veloso is not playing well. raul meireles?
  • Jonathan, Clearwater, FL USA
    13/03/2008 15:11
    first of all while these attack options seem limitless there is one large problem everyone is overlooking. If you pair Ronaldo and Deco in the center mid you have a massive defensive problem as neither player defends at all. portugal will not be able to advance in the Euro's without a strong defensive presence in the central mid. Therefor, Ronaldo needs to be left out on the flank, with Deco central and Queresma/Simoa on the left. Then pair Nani up top with Almeida. Find a strong defensive mid to play behind Deco maybe Veloso, or even try Miguel there.
  • Licinio, NJ, USA
    13/03/2008 14:36
    How can there be so little talk of Deco? he is still showing great quality for Barca. The forwards should be: Almeida up top with Nani (sub: Simao) & Ronaldo coming up the wings, with Deco playing a supporting role in central midfield. Quaresma is possibly the most overrated portugues player of this generation, as does not have the quality to be in the starting 11.
  • Taio, London
    13/03/2008 14:04
    both good posts guys, thanks. totally agree with orlandomac's idea of three players behind almeida. i'd still be very tempted to use ronaldo more central. he played as a striker three or four times for united since the turn of the year and scored in every game. if you give him a central role he could drift between joining almeida up top and playing in the hole. to be honest i'd be tempted to have a base of two wide men with almeida through the middle and just let ronaldo do whatever he wants. can you imagine if, at times, ronaldo and quaresma are doubling up on one flank - they'd be unstoppable. in recent months ronaldo has shown a better goalscorer's instinct, so i'd be equally happy for him to partner almeida in attack. let's face it, if ronaldo is the key. if he continues to score a goal every game like he's doing now the european championships are a realy possiblity for portugal.

    so, for me, it's nani (left) quaresma (right) and ronaldo drifting around behind a frontman, which is almeida with
  • Orlandomac, Toronto, Canada
    13/03/2008 13:42
    Clearly few that have read my previous posts thought I would select Quaresma but I have been known to surprise a few lol.

    Alberto made similar selections although the formations we differ on. Excellent writeup BTW Alberto, but to say that Quaresma is more talented than Ronaldo had me in stitches. Now I can appreciate my friend has watched Quar light up the Benfica D but let's get serious this is the Portuguese League we're not talking phenom Fullbacks besides Bosingwa and he only sees him on the training pitch.
    Hey I am a P/T Benfica fan but I am a realist, his success rate at the Nat team still lacks consistency. I hope he proves me wrong.

    Here are % scoring stats for the forwards. Before you have a read think of who is the top, let's see if you guess right?

    Mak 33% 1/3
    Postiga 33% 10/30
    Simao 24% 14/59
    Quar 11% 2/19
    Almeida 33% 2/6
    Ronaldo 37% 20/54
    Nani 17% 2/12
    Gomes 41% 27/67

    Now consider the likes of Gomes tops in Goals and % comes on as a sub most of the time that is an impressi
  • Alex, Zurich
    13/03/2008 13:19
    Hi guys
    From my point of view, I see it exactly the same as A. Mourinho. We should keep our 4-3-3 formation for the Euro 08 if its either Almeida, Makukula, Postiga or Gomes upfront it is too early to say. At the moment I would go for Almeida as striker and Nani aswell as Ronaldo on the wings. Anyway, if we should fall back during a match I reckon we should risk and play a 4-4-2 with Ronaldo partnering the striker upfront and play with 2 wingers (Simao, Quaresma or Nani; depends on their current form). However the most important thing is that all our attacking options get enough matches under their belt so that they'll all get in form at the right time for the Euro 08!
  • Dwight, Boston, US
    13/03/2008 13:04
    I've been a fan of Quaresma, but Nani's form at Manchester has been such that I don't know if you can leave him out the starting squad if he continues as he has been.

    At World Cup level of play, I don't know that Quaresma yet gets that you can't dribble around every defender anymore...
  • Monah Dahrouj, Lebanon
    13/03/2008 11:06
    The 3 starters have to be Ronaldo, Quaresma and Almeida.But we can't forget Helder Postiga,Nani and Simao.Postiga and Nani played so well against Belgium.And even Nani can be better than Ronaldo.The first round defines everything but we should have those 6:Quaresma nani Ronaldo Almeida simao and Postiga.


Comment on this article.

What do you think of this article? To give your opinion simply fill in the following form (max 1500 characters):

*Name:

City,Country:

Email:

*Comment (0):



*Mandatory Fields.



Home . Clubs . Liga . Portuguese Cup . Champions League
UEFA Cup . National Team . Portuguese Abroad . Player Profiles

© Copyright of PortuGoal.net 2003-2008. Design addSymbol
This site is optimised for Internet Explorer