PDF Print E-mail
Monday, 01 March 2010 15:31

Portugal’s World Cup squad: who will make the plane to South Africa?

In-depth analysis of who will be the 23 chosen ones

PortugalFootballers worldwide often say the greatest honour that can befall them is to represent their country in the World Cup. Who will be Portugal’s chosen ones boarding that plane bound for South Africa?
 
Tom Kundert takes an in-depth look at the decisions Carlos Queiroz will be mulling over as he prepares to select the 23-man squad to represent Portugal at the 2010 World Cup.
 
Given that the squad comprises 23 players, three of whom will be goalkeepers, that notionally leaves two players for each outfield position. This analysis breaks down the squad into three segments: Goalkeeper & Defenders / Midfielders / Wingers & Strikers.  
 
 

Goalkeeper and defence

 
 

Goalkeeper:

One of Queiroz’s least troublesome positions. Ever since Eduardo was installed as first-choice keeper he has made the position his own. Just two goals conceded in Portugal’s last 10 competitive games, including an ongoing run of five clean sheets, and an outstanding season for Braga makes Eduardo’s position as Portugal no. 1 incontestable.
 
Quim, after acting as back-up to first Vitor Baia then Ricardo, will naturally continue his perennial role as the national goalkeeping understudy, while the third choice seems a toss-up between Rui Patricio and Daniel Fernandes, although should Chelsea or FC Porto reserve goalkeepers Hilario and Beto get a late run of games they could push their way in.
PortuGOAL prediction: Eduardo, Quim, Rui Patricio
 
 

Right-back:

If fitness and form were not issues two obvious choices would fill this role: Chelsea’s Bosingwa and Valencia’s Miguel. The former has been out of action for months with a knee injury, although he is nearing a return, while Miguel has had an up-and-down season with Valencia and is by no means an automatic starter for the Spaniards these days.
 
However, given the pedigree and big-game experience of both defenders, provided fitness is not an issue they will both make the squad. If poor health rules one out, many feel Sporting’s Joao Pereira deserves to get the nod, although his fiery temperament counts against him, and Paulo Ferreira is more likely to be drafted in as second-choice right-back.
PortuGOAL prediction: Jose Bosingwa, Miguel
 
 

Left-back:

For all his shortcomings as a defender, Duda has made the left-back position his own, and as mentioned above Portugal’s tremendous defensive record over the past year suggests the constant criticism directed at the Malaga winger is somewhat unfair.
 
Utility defender Paulo Ferreira, another favoured target of critics and fans alike, looks odds on to be the back-up, especially as he can cover on the other flank for the injury-prone Bosingwa and hot-and-cold Miguel. Queiroz has admitted Benfica winger Fabio Coentrao is in the running for a place on the plane. Although he has performed admirably when need be for his club side at left-back, it would appear a tremendous risk to thrown on the youngster in this position against world-class opposition.
PortuGOAL prediction: Duda, Paulo Ferreira
 
 

Centre-backs:

Portugal is well served in this position, with Ricardo Carvalho and Bruno Alves forming one of the strongest central defensive partnerships in world football. The stylish Carvalho complements the more aggressive Alves perfectly, and Portugal’s hopes of making a splash in South Africa will be significantly boosted should this pair continue their form of the latter stages of the qualifying campaign.
 
Rolando and Pepe are the obvious back-ups. If Real Madrid powerhouse Pepe fails to recover from injury in time for the tournament, Fernando Meira, a hero of the 2006 World Cup, may get his chance at another tournament.
PortuGOAL prediction: Ricardo Carvalho, Bruno Alves, Rolando, Pepe (Meira if Pepe is unfit)
 
 
 
 

Midfield

Before dwelling on the individuals we have to discuss what formation Portugal are likely to adopt at the World Cup. Queiroz has so far favoured a 4-1-4-1, which broken down further can be described as a 4-1-2-2-1, with Pepe playing the holding role in an inverted triangle, Meireles and Deco slightly further up the field, feeding Portugal’s potent wingers.
 
Another alternative Queiroz has implemented, such as in the away fixture in Denmark or the final group match against Malta, is to go 4-3-3, using Simao in a more central role alongside Liedson, with Ronaldo or Nani given free licence to switch wings to provide the ammunition. Even in a conventional 4-4-2, given Portugal’s wealth of world-class wingers, at least one of the “midfielders” will spend the majority of the time in the attacking third of the pitch.
 
This all means the Portugal team in South Africa will require a three-man engine room, charged with blunting the opposition and providing a steady supply line to two wide men as well as a direct route to what is almost certain to be a lone striker. This threesome can be split into a more defensive player (Holding), the Creative source (Playmaker) and the man who has to do a bit of both (Utility).
 

Holding midfielder:

Provided he is fit there is no doubt about who will fill this role – Pepe. The Real Madrid centre-back was magnificent as an adapted holding midfielder in Portugal’s successful second half of their qualifying campaign. But the former FC Porto player is battling to overcome a cruciate knee ligament injury and his fitness for South Africa is still a question of conjecture.
 
If he doesn’t make it, Pedro Mendes is the ready-made replacement to fill his boots. The Sporting midfielder does not possess Pepe’s speed or aerial strength, but to counter these shortfalls he has a greater range of passing and can offer more going forward.
 
Despite his club side’s disastrous season, Sporting’s Miguel Veloso has earned widespread plaudits for his personal displays, suggesting he can fulfil the potential that made him one of Portugal’s hottest properties when he burst onto the scene three years ago. Manuel Fernandes is another player of whom great things were expected, but his career appears to have stalled at Valencia and it would be a big surprise if Queiroz included him in the squad:
PortuGOAL prediction: Pepe (Veloso if Pepe is unfit), Pedro Mendes
 
 

Utility midfielder:

Raul Meireles has his critics, and he has not enjoyed the best of seasons, but the fact he was the only ever-present in Portugal’s qualifying campaign tells us just how much Carlos Queiroz trusts the unfussy Porto midfielder. A certainty for the squad and a near certainty for the team.
 
Joao Moutinho has suffered immensely from the aforementioned woeful Sporting season. Whether he is one of the causes or a victim of the Lisbon side’s poor performances is open to debate, but there is no doubt the diminutive midfielder’s star has fallen over the last twelve months.
 
Tiago was described by both Jose Mourinho and Luiz Felipe Scolari as a model of consistency. He will never tear apart the opposition but equally will never allow himself to be outplayed. A wealth of big-match experience at both club and international level also counts in his favour.
PortuGOAL prediction: Raul Meireles, Tiago
 

Playmaker:

Ever since the retirement of Rui Costa Portugal has been reliant on Deco for creativity in midfield, and the Brazilian-born maestro has been superb for the Seleccao, shining brightly at Euro 2004, World Cup 2006 and Euro 2008. The 32-year-old has announced he will retire from international football after the tournament, and Portugal fans will be hoping for a memorable one last hoorah from the silky skilled playmaker.
 
In the nick of time for Portugal, a player has emerged who looks the perfect successor to Deco – Ruben Micael. The recent FC Porto recruit has been outstanding since signing from Nacional in the January transfer window. The clamour for his inclusion is so loud that the issue appears not to be whether he should make the squad, but whether or not he should be in the starting XI.
 
If either Deco or Micael are ruled out by injury, Carlos Martins could well get a call-up. The Benfica midfielder has been in excellent form this season, seamlessly stepping in for the brilliant but injury-prone Pablo Aimar for his club. The only worry concerning Martins would be his fiery temperament, with a playing history littered with red cards.
PortuGOAL prediction: Deco, Ruben Micael
 
 
 

Wingers and strikers

In line with PortuGOAL’s squad selections for the defence and midfield (excluding wingers), seven places will be up for grabs to fill the Seleccao’s attacking needs. Portugal has played with one striker up front for nigh on a decade now, achieving conspicuous success in doing so. Allied to the plethora of world-class flankers the country continues to produce, there is little doubt this will continue to be the case for most games in South Africa.
 
Should an urgent need arise for more firepower in the centre of attack, Queiroz, depending on who’s on the pitch and who’s on the bench, will have the option of pairing two genuine strikers up front or moving Ronaldo or Simao into a more central striking role, both of whom have already performed that role for Queiroz.
 
Therefore, although Portugal’s perennial lack of a top-drawer out-and-out striker remains a problem, Queiroz does have a rich pool of talent from which a whole host of attacking permutations can be drawn.
 

Wingers:

Cristiano Ronaldo. The first name to be pencilled in and the man the whole of Portugal is hoping will produce a performance in South Africa to definitively end arguments that the Madeiran is one of the greatest players ever to grace the game.
 
Two other wing wizards who Queiroz has shown every confidence in and are sure to make the plane are Nani and Simao. The former has shown moments of brilliance for Manchester United this season, albeit still striving to attain consistency, while Simao has enjoyed another excellent year for Atletico Madrid. The choice of which of the two should accompany Ronaldo on the opposite flank is sure to occupy countless café discussions up and down Portugal over the coming months.
 
Six months ago nobody would have thought it, but Silvestre Varela’s phenomenal season has probably earned the ‘Drogba of Caparica’ a chance to shine in the World Cup. Full of purposeful and selfless running, the powerful Varela has also found the net on a regular basis throughout 2009/10 and has fulfilled the potential of his early years after several seasons farmed out on loan to Portugal’s less glamorous clubs.
 
Two other wingers who on form would be knocking on the door are Ricardo Quaresma and Danny. The former, known as the ‘Harry Potter’ of Portuguese football, has done a disappearing act and only a dramatic change of circumstance at Internazionale will bring him back into contention, while Danny has also fallen out of the picture after his bad injury and scarcity of first-team football in recent months. As for Fabio Coentrao, this tournament has probably come round a season to early for the talented Benfica wide man who will certainly have a big future role to play for the national team.
PortuGOAL prediction: Ronaldo, Simao, Nani, Varela
 

Strikers:

As soon as Brazilian-born Liedson became eligible for selection, Queiroz did not hesitate in throwing the ‘Levezinho’ straight into the side, and the prolific Sporting marksman did not let anyone down, scoring what turned out to be a crucial equalising goal on his debut in Denmark.
 
Hugo Almeida was the man Queiroz entrusted the lone striker position to before Liedson was available. The big Werder Bremen front man offers something different to the attack – a big physical presence – and could also provide a good foil for Liedson should Portugal opt for a front two.
 
PAOK forward Edinho forced his way into the Portugal set-up after impressing at AEK Athens. After a brief and unsuccessful spell in the La Liga at Malaga, the pacey striker is back in Greece, playing for PAOK. Queiroz has not hesitated to call up Edinho. Two goals in a national shirt despite limited opportunities combined with the need for more striker cover should see Edinho squeeze into the squad.
 
Makukula, Nuno Gomes and Orlando Sa will believe they still have a chance of forcing their way into the party, but one feels only injury will allow it to happen. Makukula is enjoying a fantastic season in Turkey, and would appear the obvious replacement should Almeida get hurt, while the age factor will have a big bearing on the chances of the other two, with Queiroz plumping either for experience or youth.
PortuGOAL prediction: Liedson, Almeida, Edinho
 
 

Complete PortuGOAL squad:

 
Goalkeepers: Eduardo, Quim, Rui Patricio
Defenders: Bosingwa, Miguel, Duda, Paulo Ferreira, Ricardo Carvalho, Bruno Alves, Pepe, Rolando
Midfielders: Pedro Mendes, Raul Meireles, Tiago, Deco, Ruben Micael
Wingers & strikers: Cristiano Ronaldo, Nani, Simao, Varela, Liedson, Almeida, Edinho
 
 
Do you agree? PortuGOAL is always delighted to hear from its knowledgeable and passionate readership. Please leave your options using the form below.
 
 
Comments (44)
stop messing about .....CQ
44 Saturday, 12 June 2010 07:36
portugal....
can CR shine in 010 and quell all this L.Messi talk....Nani should play.....he has proven his worth at ManU......N.Gomez should be left at home with his cigar and slippers , his chance has been and gone.....as with Queresma ..not enough game time , leave CR out on the wing let him run havok!!! let Leidson lead the line alone , he is on fire!!Almedia on the bench......if CR gets the captain armband we may aswell go home now.....free his mind let his feet do the talking ....Cmon Portugal!!!!! =)
balanced team
43 Saturday, 05 June 2010 21:05
genji/ronny
The suitable formation of PORTUGAL for the upcomming world cup according to me wud be 4-1-2-2-1
.....EDUARDO.....
MIGUEL(since jose bosingwa isnt fit).. RICARDO.. ALVES.. COENTRO/ROLANDO
................PEPE.............
........MEIRELES ...DECO......
C RONALDO..... ...SIMAO......
......LEIDSON......
onle the bast playe of leen up dea love portugaa
42 Wednesday, 02 June 2010 09:01
cabdiraxaan somali
bosingwa. carvalo alves coentrao marealis deco mandes nani ronaldo dani
just one opinion
41 Monday, 17 May 2010 16:43
damir/croatia
i think portugal has got great team but i dont believe quieroz is good enough manager.
my 1st eleven:


-----------------eduardo---------------
bosingwa----carvalho----alves------duda
-------------------pepe----------------
---------meireles---------deco---------
nani----------------------------ronaldo
---------------liedson-----------------
maniche
40 Monday, 17 May 2010 13:23
anish
i think maniche should also include in center midfield ..
A real World Cup team
39 Saturday, 15 May 2010 00:42
Christiano Gomes/ United States
Eduardo
Miguel Ricardo Pepe Fabio
Carvalho Coentrao

Tiago Pedro Mendes

Nani Danny Simao

Cristiano Ronaldo
quaresma
38 Monday, 10 May 2010 03:56
qusaye
all of yall are stupid thats why your not coachs...quaresma was a great player.. and great players cant just suck all of a sudden.. the only reason quaresma sucked with inter is because of the lack of playing time...imagine messi going ten or twenty games without playing and when he gets chances he would play 3 minutes to 5.. of course you would suck soo quaresma is still a great player use him because without him there is no way in hell we will win the cup mark my words.
Jaycr lineup
37 Saturday, 03 April 2010 18:50
SupremoGino
I disagree. Miguel is the proper right-back. Left back - I guess I'll take Duda because of experience but Fabio Coentrao is looking promising. I agree with the rest of your line up but if Pepe is available.. Meireles should be replaced by Tiago for more attacking based mid.
the right squad
36 Saturday, 03 April 2010 17:08
jaycr
---------------------------------Eduardo-------------------------------
(Paulo Fereira if Bosingwa is injured)---R.Carvalho B.Alves---Duda
------------------------(Pedro Mendes if Pepe injured)------------------
--------------------- Raul Meireles-------------Deco-------------------
Cristiano Ronaldo------------------------------------------------Simao
------------------------------Liedson--------------------------------
4-1-2-2 1 formation
Weak Side?
35 Monday, 29 March 2010 11:17
Jerrold/Canada
The players aren't weak. How they are positioned and paired up will make or break the team. Queiroz is scarring me a bit though by continually experimenting. Something has to be solidified soon June will be here before we know it.
the best of the worst situation
34 Thursday, 25 March 2010 16:08
canada
There is no question that this side is extremely weak!! It does not help we have a tepid and lost coach.. The only solution is to try to ward off the oppositions attack with well distributed skill and strategy. No Boswinga, means no choice, but Miguel's return. I don't trust DUDA, but the idiot Quieroz will play him anyways..I prefer a healthy Pepe to Carvalho. As Inter Milan did against Chelsea, we have to go with a 4-3-3 formation. There is no choice.. Moreover, we need speed and an attack minded structure, so this my selection:
---------Eduardo-----
Miguel--Pepe--Alves--Ferreria
Micael--Deco--Veloso
Ronaldo--Liedson--Nani
seleccao
33 Thursday, 25 March 2010 15:20
jorge/canada
i think this should be the squad. i did not include Pepe, Bosingwa and Varela bcs they are injured.

G-Eduardo,Quim,Fernandes
D-Alves,Carvalho,Rolando,Carrico
Miguel,Ferreira,Duda,Veloso
M-Mendes,Meireles,Moutinho,Ruben,Deco
F-Liedson,Almeida,Gomes
Ronaldo,Simao,Nani,Danny

------------------------Eduardo------------------
--Miguel------Alves----Carvalho----Duda
--------------Mendes-----Meireles------------
-------------------------Deco----------------------
-------Ronaldo-----Liedson-------Simao---

Subs-Quim,Rolando,Ferreira,Veloso,Ruben,Nani,Almeida
World Cup Squad
32 Monday, 22 March 2010 14:00
Michael Cortico
My world Cup Squad would be as follows.

Eduardo
J. Pereira R.Carvalho B.Alves M.Veloso

Pepe

Nani Pedro Mendes J.Moutinho

Liedson C.Ronaldo




Substitutes Would be:
Hugo Almeida
Simao Sabrosa
Quaresma
Tiago
Duda
Rui Patricio
Paulo Ferreira
Injuries
31 Thursday, 11 March 2010 11:44
Jerrold/ Canada
I just heard Bosingwa is out for the season, that includes the WC. Pepe is still out on injury as is Carvalho and Deco. These are huge assets to the team. Will they be ready in time for the WC?
Who should be the team captain?
30 Thursday, 11 March 2010 11:24
Jerrold/ Canada
I love C. Ronaldo to death but he is too much of a wild card to be in a Captains position. I think it should go to someone with more control like Deco. I really think is an under estimated player for his ability to set the pace. I'd even give it to Carvalho or Simao. Not as punishment to C. Ronaldo but just to give him space and keep him in check.
Tiago?
29 Tuesday, 09 March 2010 23:20
Sam/Usa
Dan/USA, Where is Tiago in your 23?, he was one of the most consistent performers for the seleccao against China, and is enjoying a superb season for Atletico, other than that, I approve of the inclusion of Hugo Viana. If Joao Pereira starts playing more, then I would include him too
My Thoughts on the Final 23
28 Friday, 05 March 2010 04:23
Dan/USA
Goalkeepers: Eduardo, Quim, R.Patrício
Defenders: Bosingwa, Miguel, Joao Pereira, R.Carvalho, Pepe, Bruno Alves, Rolando
Midfielders: C.Ronaldo, Simao, Nani, Varela, R.Micael, Deco, J.Moutinho, Hugo Viana, M.Veloso
Forwards: Nuno Gomes, Liedson, H.Almeida, Makukula

-----------------------------Eduardo---------------------------
Bosingwa------R.Carvalho-----B.Alves---------Miguel------------
--------------------------------Pepe---------------------------
C.Ronaldo-----------------Deco-----------------------Simao----
-----------------Liedson-----------------H.Almeida------------

My final 23...
Goalkeepers: Eduardo, Quim, R.Patricio
Eduardo's are number one right now and the real question here is who will be our back-ups...I think Quim and Patricio deserve to make the final cut...Yea there not big fans of some, but at least they play week in and week out unlike the other goalkeepers who hardly see a minute for their clubs

Defenders: Bosingwa, Miguel, Joao Pereira, R.Carvalho, Pepe, Bruno Alves, Rolando
We all know Bosingwa, Carvalho, Pepe, and Bruno Alves deserve to be in South Africa...I decided to choose Miguel, Pereira, and Rolando to provide cover...IMO Miguel should be our starting left-back...Everybody that CQ tested to play that position has unimpressed and I think Miguel should get a shot...Pereira and Rolando are there just as back ups...IMO Pereira's call-up is long overdue and while I'm not a big fan of Rolando, his the only good back up center-back we have...It would be good for him to get some experience at a major International competition to prepare himself for Euro 2012 because I'm sure he will be our starting center-back by then

Midfielders: C.Ronaldo, Simao, Nani, Varela, R.Micael, Deco, J.Moutinho, Hugo Viana, M.Veloso
Ronaldo, Simao, Nani, and Deco are going no doubt...They have the experience at being in big competitions and should play a big role in our attacking play...Now for our back-ups Varela, R.Micael, and Hugo Viana should be the so called surprise call-ups, but I know the idiot will only pick one of those three to make the squad which is a shame because they are having fantasic seasons for their clubs...Moutinho and Veloso round out the midfield list...Both players are capable of getting the job done if called upon...Also Veloso is another player who should get a look at, at left-back

Forwards: Nuno Gomes, Liedson, H.Almeida, Makukula
Really wish we had more opitions here, but we all know our forward pool isn't that great...Liedson is clearly our main forward while Almeida can also be put in that category...Now I know Nuno and Makukula are surprising to see on my list, but "Big Mak" is having himself a fine season in Turkey and getting the call up for the world cup would only boost his confidence...Now I know Nuno shouldn't even be here since he hardly plays, but Nuno still adds something that no one else on the squad does, experience...He doesn't have to see a single minute of playing time, but he would be a good player for all the guys in the locker room...His experienced some high and low moments at big competitions and could share his experience with other players, espeacially all the forwards on the team since this will be their first time at the world cup...

Now for anybody wondering why I left out these players: Hilário, Beto, and Daniel Fernandes...Hilario and Beto hardly see minutes and Fernandes isn't good enough to be on the NT...P.Ferreira, Tonel, F.Meira, Duda, Ricardo Costa, Peixoto...Paulo doesn't play at all and always sucked...Duda, Costa, and Peixoto are average players and I like Tonel and Meria, but feel Rolando gets the nod over them since his younger and will play a role for us in the future...Mendes, Tiago, Manuel Fernandes, Maniche, Danny, Quaresma, Coentrao, Meireles...I like all these players except for Merdales...Mendes fails to make my list because I feel we need the younger players to get the experience, but if Pepe fails to recover then Mendes takes his spot for sure...Tiago is good, but feel there are better players ahead of him...Maniche's International career ended a long time ago...Danny, Fernandes, and Quaresma don't get any playing time...Love Coentrao, but his still to young to make the final squad....No doubt he will be in our Euro 2012 campagin and lastly screw Raul Merdales...I see nothing in him and hope he gets injuried because thats the only way CQ won't call him up...And lastly Edinho and Djalo are two good fast players, but both players finishing isn't that great...They might bring speed, but finishing is the key to getting the call up...However both players, as well as many will be in our Euro 2012 plans...

With that said I hope these group of players change our recent play around, but just don't see it happening with CQ at the helm...We have the talent to make it far, but this team lacks the leadership and discipline to band together...Notice how the last player, Figo, brought all that and we played some amazing games against some tough teams...After he left the NT for good our NT hasn't been the same...Lets wait and see what happens this summer...I'm hoping for the best, but preparing for the worst
No left back?
27 Thursday, 04 March 2010 22:56
Filipe/ Texas
How can some of you suggest coentrao and veloso as starting left backs!!! You must be Brazilian spies... If Duda isn't fit, it has to be P. Ferreira, despite his shortcomings at that position. Some of you despise Duda, but he is a solid defender and above average on going forward. Excellent at frr kicks on the right side of the field. He has a nice in-swing with his left.

Also, more than one of you has mentioned we are poor at free kicks. That is laughable. Has anyone seen the Tomahawk lately?!?!?! Arguably we have 3 of the top 10 free kick takers in LaLiga. Ronaldo, simao, duda.
Enough is Enough
26 Thursday, 04 March 2010 22:00
Tony/Canada
I don't know about you but I'm tired of all line-up tinkering. It seems like every game someone new gets a try-out, no wonder there is no chemistry and we struggled in qualifications. Queiroz has a lot of talent to choose from, so no matter who he picks we will be strong. My only advice is to end the Duda experiment, he is not good enough defensively, instead pick someone who plays that position everyday, hopefully someone with height and speed. keep Ronaldo on the wings on not alone up front, he will be involved in the game much more and raising hell for the opponents. Lets hope Pepe is back because in my opinion he has been our best and most consistant player since he joined our team.
Lineup
25 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 22:23
SupremoGino
A real world cup lineup would look like this.

-----------Eduardo-------------
Miguel----Carvalho----Alves----Coentrao/Veloso
-----------------Pepe------------------
--------Micael----Deco-------------
C.Ronaldo----------------Simao
----------------Liedson---------------

It's all about consistancy and experience. Forget about recent form.

Bench: Quim, Paulo Ferreira, Bosingwa, Joao Moutinho, Tiago, Meireles, Quaresma, Nani, Varela, Hugo Almeida, Nuno Gomes

There is your 23-man squad. Every single one of them deserves to be in the squad and Deco/Gomes/Carvalho should be captain not Ronaldo.
my team, the only team that can bring the cup to lisbon
24 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 21:13
the manager
--------------------Eduardo-------------------
bosingwa----carvalho---b.alves-----duda
-------------------------pepe----------------------
-------------------tiago----------------------------
c.ronaldo---------------- deco---------------
----------------------------------------------simao
-------------------almeida------------------------
team chemistry
23 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 19:09
psousanj
Adding to my point I would play veloso and moutinho together as they have a repor and if necessary in the midfield...you can say they are inconsistent or young but don't forget the very low profile midfield during 2004 that all played at porto last time I checked maniche and costinha where not superstars don't forget their familiarity with nani and liedson...on the other hand you could play (assuming pepe is back) with pepe meireles and micael/deco and possibly varela on the wing....I just think chemistry and faniliarity is vital to us succeding. Regarding the tiago point I see tiago as a player who regreses when in big spots(juve,chelsea) and is basically average in every way he has no defining skill I think meirels is a more athletic dynamic choice

Thanx for the feedback TOM
We can do it
22 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 18:22
Rui/Madeira
this kind of reports,comments are great to see.Last year who would think about articles like this published here in Portugal.net.I can still remember some of you, guys commenting about euro 2012.We all prayed,dreamed at last that dream come true.Now we are discussing about the squad which CQ might select for championship.
some might be say that Portuguese have no chance in 2010 but please my portugol friends never stop the dreaming and praying.
Sorry for my bad English!
Weaknesses
21 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 18:05
Joe NJ USA
Lets look at our weaknesses.

One for sure is finishing, and being able to turn time of possession and opportunities in the box into actual goals. Remedy? Ronaldo and Simao, who seemingly score at will for their club teams. We need them to find the net with the National team. During qualification we relied too much on getting goals form the likes of Alves & Meireles.

Another is left back. Yeah we don't have a world class individual here. Personally I don't mind Ferreira as much as the rest of you. What he lacks in talent he makes up in effort, and sometimes effort is a better benefit than talent (this is true across all sports). Despite our wishes to see Veloso here Queiroz will play Duda. What makes anyone think otherwise. So its a mute point.

Finally another big weakness is set pieces. Scolari was terrified of these, and rightfully so. I'm lways very nervous about our aerial defending in the box. If Pepe is not fit, Meira HAS to be called. Though I like Mendes, he just has no size. We have a team stocked with smallish individuals and can't leave Alves/Carvalho alone to defend against a taller opposition (esp. with Ronaldo's lack luster effort on defense). If Pepe is unfit I think Meira has to be on the field to provide that tall physical presence in the box for set kicks and corners.
Great feedback - keep it coming
20 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 17:06
Tom Kundert / Portugal
Loving all your ideas. Maybe I should print out this discussion and send it to the FPF c/o C. Queiroz!

A pervading idea in relation to the squad in the article is the inclusion of Miguel Veloso. There is no doubt he has been excellent this season. But we have to remember that to include x,y, or z you also have to think who would drop out?

I agree with PSousa that you can also consider Veloso a utility midfielder, although I believe he can do a good job holding, so it would be Pepe, Mendes, Tiago or Meireles to drop out. Pepe (if fit) and Meireles are certs, and I think the experience of Mendes and Tiago just give them the edge over Veloso.

Having him as the back-up left-back would be a bit of a risk, and Queiroz isn't one to take risks. Imagine Duda gets crocked and we're relying on Veloso, who has only played left-back occassionally against some Liga Sagres opponents, to stop the world's best right wingers/attacking midfielders. For all his failings, at least Duda's had a year in the role and is in sync with the rest of the defence.

But it's certainly a tricky connundrum. My colleague Andy Brassell said he thought Queiroz would take Veloso instead of Micael, but I agree with Filipe from Texas. We need Micael's creativity there as stand-in for Deco who's a bit injury prone these days...
good thing none of you are the coach
19 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 16:28
filipe/ texas
There are only 1 or 2 of you that were capable of selecting proper starting 11. Some of you would have us insert 3/4 newcomers into the starting 11. I have 24 players below, Micael may not make it, and in that case, Tiago or Moutinho step into that role, and Veloso fills their hole. That is how you get to 23, unless you leave Veloso off and give Micael a spot. I wouldn't be surprised, we need creativity in the absence of Deco, and only Micael can deliver that currently.

----------------------Eduardo------------------------
----------------------(Quim)-------------------------
----------------------(Hilario)----------------------

--Bosingwa-------B. Alves-----R. Carvalho---------------Duda
--(Miguel/P.Ferreira)------(Rolando)-------------(P. Ferreira)

--------------------------Pepe------------------------------
-----------------------(P. Mendes)--------------------------
------------------------(Veloso)----------------------------

----------------R. Miereles------------Tiago----------------
----------------------(Moutinho)----------------------------

----Ronaldo----------------Deco------------------Simao
----(Nani)--------------(R. Micael)------------(Varela)

---------------------------Almeida------------------------
---------------------------(Liedson)----------------------
no one mentioned makukula but lex
18 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 14:29
oliver/berlin
its no wonder you people always lose. You pick nuno gomes who hasnt played consistently over a guy thats on a scoring clinic over in turkey.

My prediction is that Germany will beat portugal for the 3rd time straight.
NT SELECTION
17 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 13:36
george/usa
there are very nice selections here on the site. heres what i think that veloso and moutinho should not be selected, why because they think they the shit. they have not played good all season except for the game vs porto and everton in the past week. those two sporting games were great. why cant those two sporting players play good all season? i dont know about simao, i worry about him. i think queiroz should take danny back he fits great for nt. not sure about mendez, edinho, makukula, ruben, meireles, querasema and coentrano.
my selection for nt would be:

quim
miguel, pepe, alves, bosigwa
tiago
danny, deco, nani
ronaldo, liedson

reserves:
nuno gomes, ruben, varela, simao, rui, duda, mendez, carvalho, fernandez, coetrano, eduardo, queresma, (1 more mid)
national team
16 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 11:46
Grilo
----------------------eduardo-------------------
bosingua--------carvalho--------b.alves-------pepe
--------------------p mendes----------------------
r. micael-------------meireles--------deco--------
--------------ronaldo---------liedson-------------
DEFENSIVE MID?
15 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 05:50
psousanj
Lol Miguel Veloso is your utility midfielder not dm he is not physical enough and part of his strength is his passing range and vision along with a wicked long shot.....he is a box to box player don't limit him to sitting back as did sporting in the past now that he has mendes doing the dirty work he's free to do what he does best I'd compare him xabi alonso......my lineup

Eduardo
Bosimgwa carvalho alves miguel
Pepe
Moutinho/micael. Veloso/meireles

Ronaldo. Nani
Liedson

If simao plays he will dissappear against better opposition like he always does for the nt and now for atleti
Veloso has to go
14 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 04:58
David from England (via Australia)
I think Miguel Veloso has to go. Queiroz seems intent on playing Duda at left back and as great as he is in midfield for Malaga, he's a liability defensively. Paulo ferreira rarely plays and is inconsistent and Fabio Coentrao would be amazing against North Korea but a nightmare against the other two.
Fair enough Veloso isn't a regular left back but he has a lot more experience there for club and Portugal youth and is more defensively minded.
Bring Veloso as back up for Mendes or Pepe and when Kalou tears Duda apart, Queiroz can put Veloso in there.
I'd also love to see Quaresma there (magic when he's confident and on form, should have started last tournament over Simao) and Yannick Djalo gives you a different kind of striker but you can't bring everybody.
national squad
13 Tuesday, 02 March 2010 01:29
the neutral
--------------------Eduardo---------------
bosingwa--Carvalho--Alves--Pepe
------------Miereles--Tiago-------------
Nani------------Ronaldo---------Simao
-------------------Almeida-----------------

Formation:4-2-3-1
Use pepe as a leftback however if he is not fit use veloso. I would implement miereles and tiago both as utility midfielders. i would allow ronaldo to roam freely as he does in real madrid but would put him as a central attacking midfielder. Both nani and simao would play their respective wings, and hopefully aim crosses for both almeida and ronaldo.
squad and team
12 Monday, 01 March 2010 23:23
nuno gomes
STarting

-----------------------Quim--------------------------------------
Bosingwa------R carvalho-------Pepe(alves if not ready)---Peixoto

----------------Pedro Mendes/Raul Mereieles----------------------

Cristiano Ronaldo------------------------------------Simao Sabrosa

-----------------------------Deco-----------------------------------

-------------Nuno Gomes(C)-------------Liedson----------------------



or


-------------------------------Quim----------------------------------------

Bosingwa----------R carvalho----------Pepe(alves if not ready)------Peixoto

-------------------------Pedro Mendes--------------------------------------

------------------Raul Meireiles-----------------Deco---------------------

Cristino Ronaldo----------------------------------------------Simao Sabrosa

-----------------------------Liedson/Nuno Gomes-----------------------------

Bench:Eduardo, Miguel, Veloso,Nuno Gomes,Nani,Tiago,Coentrao
Int'l Squad
11 Monday, 01 March 2010 21:54
Gogetta / USA
I like the squad you've chosen, due to the circumstances. I think that our biggest weakness will be left-back, especially vs Brazil. Maicon will have a field day vs Duda or P. Ferreira. Duda has proven serviceable, but Ferreira has done anything but. The best left back Portugal has is Peixoto, but unfortunately Jesus himself is playing around with Coentrao, who is not ready for the World Cup.
I also think that moving Cristiano upfront takes away a great weapon flying up the side. He takes on defenders and creates free kicks. Man United and even Real, in my opinion, are losing a lot of his effectiveness moving him there for large portions of the game.

My starting squad: 4-1-4-1

----------------------Eduardo-------------------

Boswinga - Carvalho - Alves - Rolando
--------------------Pepe------------------------
-------------Micael - Veloso----------------
Simao -------------------------- Cristiano
------------------Liedson-----------------------

This is obviously based on everyone being healthy.

Full Squad
Goalies: Eduardo, Quim, anyone but Hilario who has looked inept at Chelsea.
Right Back: Boswinga & Miguel
Center Backs: Carvalho, Alves with Rolando and Pepe being the backups, but if the starters go down we are done.
Left Back: I would either move Rolando there or even Veloso with Duda being the backup.
Holding Mid: Pepe and Mendes
Mids Utility& Attacking: Micael & Veloso with Deco, Tiago and Martins as backups
Wingers: Cristiano & Simao with Nani and Varela as backups.
Strikers: Liedson, Almeida & Edinho.

Guys I left out:
Meireles has been awful this season.
Moutinho hasn't shown anything, and has never looked good vs Int'l competition.
Coentrao is not ready.

Guys that shouldn't be considered:
Quaresma hasn't played.
Sa hasn't played.
Makukula is doing it in Turkey. Is that enough?
I would like to see Nuno Gomes get a farewell tour, but Edinho has produced when given a chance. Almeida has also looked good since coming back from injury.
MY SQUAD!
10 Monday, 01 March 2010 21:37
Miggy --- England
Goalkeepers: Eduardo, Quim, Rui Patricio
Defenders: Bosingwa, Duda, Paulo Ferreira, Ricardo Carvalho, Bruno Alves, Pepe(Meira if he doesn't make it), Rolando
Midfielders: Pedro Mendes, Raul Meireles, Tiago, Deco, Ruben Micael, M.Veloso, Moutinho
Wingers & strikers: Cristiano Ronaldo, Nani, Simao,Liedson, Almeida, Nuno Gomes.

I think it's all very balanced this way.
Finland
9 Monday, 01 March 2010 21:06
Samu
It's weird how yours predictions don't include Nani. He has been superb lately and i'm sure that we will see more from him until end of the season. He causes problems to every defence in the world, surely starter at seleccao!
Squad
8 Monday, 01 March 2010 20:50
Mattheiro
Keepers: Eduardo(Braga),Quim(Benfica),Rui Patricio(Sporting)

Defenders:Carvalho(Chelsea), Alves(Porto), Rolando(Porto), Ricardo Costa(Lille)or Pepe (If fit), Bosingwa(Chelsea), Miguel(Valencia), Peixoto(Benfica), Coentrao(Benfica)

Midfielders: Deco(Chelsea), Micael(Porto), Moutinho(Sporting), Mendes(Sporting), Meireles(Porto)

Forwards: Makukula(Kayserispor), Almeida(Bremen), Liedson(Sporting), Ronaldo(Real Madrid), Simao(A.Madrid), Nani(Manchester United), Varela(Porto)

Starting Line Up: 4-4-1-1
Right to Left

Eduardo
Bosingwa,Carvalho,Alves,Peixoto
Ronaldo,Moutinho,Meireles,Simao(C)
Micael
Almeida

Second Line Up: 4-1-3-1-1
Right to Left
Eduardo
Miguel,Carvalho(C),Alves,Peixoto
Mendes
Ronaldo,Meireles,Simao
Micael
Almeida

Forca Portugal
I WANT MORE QUARESMA!!!
7 Monday, 01 March 2010 20:34
ricardo g.
carlos queiroz should call up quaresma, even though he don't play much with inter he's still a great player that could really help portugal win games and dominate along side with c.ronaldo and nani they would be a very dangerous threat to anybody!! It would also be the best thing that could happen to him cause it would give ricardo alot more confidence in himself and he will snap out of his slump and play better for inter milan
my team
6 Monday, 01 March 2010 20:25
jon/usa
Drop Edinho and put in Nuno Gomes, he has tons of experience and in my opinion is much better than edinho.

------------Eduardo----------
Bosingwa--Carvalho-Alves--Veloso
----------------Pepe-----------
---------Micael-----Meireles------
Ronaldo---Liedson---Simao

In my opinion this is the best possible team. Duda should be dropped, HE IS OUR WEEKNESS. I am 100% positive that if Portugal plays aginst the best players in the world, Duda will be crucified! Veloso actually plays left back a lot and also is very good at crossing. Even though it is hard to see it Meireles is an important part of the seleccao and I think a partnership with Micael would work because they play together at porto.
IMO
5 Monday, 01 March 2010 20:14
miguel/ usa
Veloso has to be included in the squad. As far as my formation I think a 4-2-3-1 would suit us greatly.

----------------------Eduardo-------------------
-Bosingwa---Carvalho---Alves---Duda/Veloso-
------------------Pepe---Meireles---------------
-Ronaldo-----------Deco------------Nani/Simao-
----------------------Liedson--------------------
Great Article!
4 Monday, 01 March 2010 18:16
David/Portugal
-I strongly believe Portugal should play with two holding midfielders. Those being Pepe and Mendes. (Veloso is a great option if Pepe doesn't recover in time)
-In the attacking midfielder's position I'm not sure whether to start Deco or Rúben.
-My next point I strongly believe in is that Ronaldo should play up front (just like Ferguson admitted he did with United)
That being said, Simão will take the left winger's position and Varela will take the right (I struggled to decide between him and Nani but going on recent form Varela is the obvious choice)
4-2-3-1 (Very balanced between defense and attack)

-------------Ronaldo-----------------
Simão-------Deco--------Varela
---------Pepe--------P.Mendes-------
Duda-B.Alves-Carvalho-Bosingwa
------------Eduardo-------------
YANNICK DJALO
3 Monday, 01 March 2010 17:37
Monah/Lebanon
It's almost alright!! bit why nobody is thinking about YANNICK DJALO! he's a talented striker, and he can be a third option with Liedson and Almeida...
my squad
2 Monday, 01 March 2010 17:01
lex/canada
-----------Eduardo------------
Bosingwa-Carvalho-B.Alves-Duda
------------Pepe--------------
------Ruben--------Tiago-------
Ronaldo------------------Varela
-----------Makukula------------
my opinion
1 Monday, 01 March 2010 16:29
Rick/Toronto
I would take Veloso in a heartbeat ...leave Edinho off the squad, and use a combo of either Ronaldo, Varela or even Simao as a third striker option.

Veloso is in great form, and shows a greta deal of versatility to play in numerous positions on field..leaving him of this squad would be a travesty.

the rest of the squad is pretty much bang on, although i wish Coentrao could find a spot, but he'll be important in our chances of qualifying for Euro 2012.

Add your comment

Name/Country:
Subject:
Comment:
 
Live Scores